Part 1:
My attempt to engage in a conversation
with my sister for 15 minutes without using symbolic language was unsuccessful
to say the least. I found it very difficult because I communicate on a day to
day basis with speech.
My sister had absolutely no idea what I
was trying to say. She stared at me with the most confused face I have ever
seen. I'm not sure if that means she isn’t the brightest light bulb in the room
or if I looked like an untamed chimpanzee. It was difficult to stay in
character and not say a word because we both kept laughing. There was a few
occasions where I would shout a sentence out of frustration and she would
respond, "That's nothing close to what you gestured!" . I don't think I am the
only person who had difficulties with this form of communication because
society in general is used to talking all the time, even if it's excessive.
If we had been two different cultures
meeting for the first time, I would think the person who lives in an
environment that required them to adapt to communicating without symbolic language
would have an advantage.
The people who use symbolic language
most likely look down on the people who do not use symbolic language. I say
that because symbolic language is so common in this day and age, it's like
breathing. So someone who is unable to communicate using symbolic language could
be absolutely shocking and unbelievable to most people.
Nail salons are a prime example of
communication difficulty among individuals. Most employees at nail salons have
came over seas and only speak Vietnamese, Chinese, Japanese, Thai, etc. A
description of a typical nail salon customer is a Caucasian female who speaks
only English. I have seen many instances where customers get irritated with the
employees because they do not understand the specifications of what type of
service they would like. On the other hand, employees at these salons get
frustrated trying to explain themselves to their customers and normally give up
on their attempt and do whatever the customer wants.
Part 2:
My attempt to communicate with my
sister only using speech was almost as difficult as not being able to use any
speech. I am partially Italian and if you know anything about Italians you know
they're loud and use hand gestures for everything.
I'm
almost certain my sister thought I was wearing a strap attaching my arms to my
waist. Standing completely still made my voice go monotone and I felt like a
statue. As a result my sister was completely bored with the conversation and
felt it was bland.
I believe the use of "signs" and non-speech
language techniques in our language is very important because it adds animation
and life to the topic that is being discussed.
There are people who have difficulty
reading body language because they're not use to or don't understand it. The
ability to read another person's body language is helpful because you could
establish if the person is being truthful or not. For example, when I say, "Hey
let's go to the gym!" and my sister says, "Ok" while dragging her feet, I know
she doesn't really want to go. But if she says, "Ok" and shoots out of her chair,
I know she wants to go.
I feel the best situation to be
incapable of reading a person's body language is in a hospital. Seeing a person
in pain is not a pretty sight. It's sad, depressing, and would make me feel bad
for not being able to do anything in that second to relieve them from their
pain.
Hi,
ReplyDeleteI do agree with you that it was not easy to communicate without using speech and that is mainly because we use speech in our daily lives and it would harder if we did not have speech to get our business done I believe we would be an a lot slower world without speech
Good, and humorous, description of your Part 1 experiment.
ReplyDelete"If we had been two different cultures meeting for the first time, I would think the person who lives in an environment that required them to adapt to communicating without symbolic language would have an advantage."
Ah, but that wasn't the question. Which culture would have the advantage in communicating complex ideas? Can you explain Einstein's theory of relativity without symbolic language? How about Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection? Could you even do science without symbolic language?
I actually chuckle when students say they an especially difficult time with Part 2 because of their ethnic heritage. :-) ALL cultures use body language, and while some might use body language in a more energetic fashion, it is equally hard for all ethnic groups to NOT use body language.
"I believe the use of "signs" and non-speech language techniques in our language is very important because it adds animation and life to the topic..."
It certainly makes it more interesting, but it is actually more important then that. Humans use body language to validate what they are hearing. Is that person telling the truth? What does their body language tell me? Without that confirmation, we don't know if we can trust what we are hearing, like a missing lie detector. That makes us uncomfortable.
There is variation among humans in their ability to read body language, but can you identify a specific group of people with a certain condition that is characterized by the inability to read body language?
While I see your point in the final comment, this is an issue of comfort, not survival. Are there any circumstances where body language might mislead you? Can it be misinterpreted? Do all cultures use the same system of body language?